The U.S. nicotine pouch market is entering its toughest test yet. On one side is real, tangible progress: smoke-free innovation and a growing demand for smoke-free products from adults who are currently using combustible tobacco products. On the other hand, there is a shadow market that cuts corners, blurs origins, and erodes trust. With enforcement ramping up and scrutiny intensifying, responsible retailing isn’t just a nice-to-have; it’s the backbone of credibility, consumer protection, and the viability of the category’s future.
The Cracks Are Showing: Illicit Trade, Eroding Trust
In the Future Shopper Report 2023, consumer research shows that roughly one in six in-store shoppers cite ‘trust/authenticity’ as a primary reason they don’t buy online. That’s not a trivial number. It’s a visible crack in the foundation and a clear signal that doubt is already shaping real-world behavior. When 16 percent of potential offline customers question whether what they’re buying is genuine, properly labeled, or offered by a retailer willing to stand behind it, the entire category risks stagnation or collapse.
That hesitation doesn’t happen by accident. Illicit products, from unauthorized imports to mislabeled shipments and outright counterfeits, are flooding through distribution channels. A recent Reuters investigation found nearly a 90 percent mismatch between U.S. import records and partner nations, underscoring just how much product may be entering under false declarations.
These middlemen, including customs brokers, distributors, and brokers operating from residential addresses, enable and amplify illicit supply chains that evade scrutiny. In short, rogue players are creating noise and leverage precisely where consumer confidence should stand firm.
Enforcement Has Arrived and It’s Now Nonnegotiable
The industry has asked, and the regulators have now answered: they will no longer issue polite reminders. It’s about action. In a recent FDA and CBP joint operation, authorities seized nearly $34 million worth of illegal e-cigarette products. Many shipments had vague labeling or incorrect information, indicating an attempt to evade customs controls or other regulatory reviews.
FDA Commissioner Marty Makary has taken a step further, making it clear in his recent statement that retailers can no longer turn a blind eye. Too many have willfully sold unauthorized products, and his message leaves no room for doubt: this is no longer a gentle reminder; it’s a warning. To drive home the point, the FDA is mailing materials to more than 300,000 retailers. Those packets include the 20 nicotine pouch products that can be legally marketed in the U.S., access to the new Searchable Tobacco Product Database, and fresh education resources to reinforce vendor responsibilities.
Back in July, the commissioner also flagged the porous nature of U.S. ports, calling illicit vapes a kind of “attack” on American youth and pledging stronger seizure powers at the border.
In short, the regulatory pendulum has swung firmly toward enforcement. The question for retailers is whether they take action against illicit products or become collateral in a policy crackdown.
A Responsible Retailer Model: How Haypp Stands Apart
At Haypp, our approach has always been proactive. As an e-commerce retailer, the scrutiny is even higher, which is why we operate our sites, Nicokick.com and Northerner.com, on the belief that integrity must be baked into every step of the supply chain. Here’s how we differentiate ourselves in practice.
- Selective Curation, Not Blind Stocking
We don’t just fill virtual shelves. Every brand and every pouch undergoes a rigorous vetting process aligned with industry best practices. If a provider cannot demonstrate credentials, lab results, or compliance records, including proof of compliance with FDA guidance and requirements, we don’t offer it to our consumers. - Rigorous Testing Backed by Transparency
Inspired by testing frameworks that align with regulatory expectations, we require accurate nicotine labeling, well-controlled pH levels, and screening for heavy metals and other contaminants. We generate our own third-party verification by taking ownership of the requirements and adding substance to our supplier’s product propositions. - Continuous Monitoring and Adaptive Oversight
Regulations will continue to evolve—and so must we. We stay ahead of enforcement trends, so our customers never bear the cost of regulatory surprise.
Because of this approach, every pouch we offer is one we believe in and one you can rely on.
Why the Retailer You Choose Matters as Much as the Pouch
Buying from a disreputable vendor is always a gamble. The product in your hand might be untested, mislabeled, or never legally cleared for sale. And that risk doesn’t just taint a single purchase; it erodes confidence in the entire marketplace.
By contrast, choosing a responsible retailer delivers something far greater than convenience: assurance. Proof that what you’re buying is legitimate, documented, and backed by accountability.
In a market where trust is fragile, every purchase speaks volumes. It tells the industry that consumers won’t accept ambiguity. That they expect higher standards. Those shortcuts won’t be tolerated.
At Northerner, our commitment is clear: transparency, vigilance, and responsibility. Not because it’s easy, but because it’s the only way this category moves forward and endures.
This is sponsored content.